Wanting this test of the two cloths to be fair, I used the same crochet non pattern for each one. For the cotton yarn cloth, I chained 26, then single crocheted in the second chain from the hook, and continued with a single crochet in each chain to the end of the row. At the end of the row, I chained one, turned and repeated the single crochet process, row after row, until the cloth was a square-ish shape I liked.
For the cotton thread cloth, I followed the same non pattern, but I crocheted with 2 threads, combining the variegated and the dark blue on the hook, and I began the cloth by chaining 52 instead of But I had to compare them. Into the soapy water they went …. After washing a few things, I brought the dishcloths out to the line to dry in the sunshine. The cotton yarn cloth held its shape more consistently than the cotton thread cloth on the line.
But the cotton thread cloth would probably dry faster than the cotton yarn cloth. Try more than one You'll love em! I'm both a knitter and a crocheter, but I've only made crocheted dishclothes, so I will have to knit some to do a comparison.
The performance of a dishcloth really depends on the pattern anyway. Here is my favorite crocheted dishcloth pattern in terms of performance:. This makes a thinner, stretchy dishcloth that wrings well and dries fast, so maybe there is something to what you are saying. Pretty crocheted lacy dishclothes are nice to look at, but when it comes to every-day utility, I prefer an even fabric that is not too hole-y and not too thick. I guess a simple knitted fabric fits the bill.
On the other hand, I'm a sucker for pretty stitches made by crochet. Well, to be quite honest, I've never actually seen with my own eyes nor used a knitted dishcloth.
But I would guess that being a novice knitter AT BEST and not really knowing anybody else who knits OR crochets my mother used to, but carpal tunnel and arthritis have prevented her from continuing might have something to do with that. And I've only recently discovered the joy that is dishcloth making. Although I have to say that the ones I've made so far were so pretty that I decided they couldn't be used for dishes. I've kept them for washcloths instead.
I did have a thought, though. If you've got a heavy yarn, it seems to me that it would be harder to wring out and dry out, for that matter , than a thinner one. Just my two cents, for whatever it's worth. I've both knit and crocheted dishclothes and like the feel of the knitted ones better. The knit ones are less bulky than the crocheted ones, in my opinion.
They also fold up more easily to store in my kitchen linen drawer. I make both crocheted and knitted dishcloths I like either knit or crochet really, no preference, but I will never buy dishcloths again, I will always make them They are superior scrubbers in my opinion.
My family is always after me to make them more, more more! There are pros and cons of both I guess. It really depends on which patterns you use. I have a book of 99 crocheted patterns Leisure Arts "The Big Book of Dishcloths" , and some are better than others at scrubbing and some dry out faster than others too.
For me it takes a lot longer to knit a cloth as opposed to crocheting one, so if speed is a factor then crochet wins I always use either bernat handicrafter cotton or sugar n cream cotton yarns. For versatility in patterns I have to give it to crochet, because of all the lacy stitches and various shapes you can do. And as to whether hand-made cloths are better than store bought ones, well all you have to do is walk by a craft stall or show and see people buying them up like hotcakes.
And people were paying it like it was nothing! I have to say I prefer the knit dishclothes, they use up much less cotton, aren't as thick and hold up just as well if not better with repeated washings I have to say I like knitted ones better too.
My first knit project was a dishcloth in a 2 stitch check pattern and I absolutely love it. It camd out so pretty I gave it to one of my South African Aunties. Blue Sugar n Cream it was. I prefer knitted for face and body washing and crochet for dishes. I suppose its because that way I can keep them separate in the laundry.
I use a lot more wash cloths in the kitchen and I crochet a lot faster than I knit. Even my husband likes them in the kitchen, though he does make occasional comments about my bright color choices :. This may sound crazy, but what exactly is a dishcloth? I had assumed that they were teatowels, but the photos I've seen look more like face washers for the kitchen. I like the sound of what -tamaratamara- said about replacing paper towel with them, but it sounds like some people actually wash dirty dishes with them??
Just seeking clarification! Or wipe off the counter, or be doubled up and used as a potholder, or be given as a give with some fancy soap I've never knit one and I don't intend to.
I'm too busy tying knitted thingies around poles and fences and such! I think people use them for a variety of things. Personally I prefer them as wash cloths for use in the shower but my daughter likes them for hand washing dishes.
Clarissa in Querce Posted 13 years ago. Edited by Clarissa in Querce member 13 years ago. I have to admit that I share some of Sharmanizzle's concerns, or better "shared. And even now, I don't really understand how people in the US can use a dishcloth for dishes, when the purpose of washing dishes is to scrub and the dishcloth doesn't seem to be that "scrubby.
Now, for my Italian friend, I have to explain to them what a dishcloth is, and most likely they're going to use it to wipe dishes, pans and pots, or to clean a countertop. Whatever is its usage, I hope they'll think of me when handle it. So, now my knitting mojo is back :o. Sharmanizzle 13 years ago. I am still unconvinced. I got the sugar and cream stuff people recommended and NOPE.
Dish cloths just ain't my thing. I'll stick to scarfs and fingerless gloves and beanies. Those have more use for me. I love that I posted on this in and there are still people responding.
How awesome is that? I haven't even logged back in on this one since Thanks KayTay for reminding me I posted this so long ago. YarnChic 13 years ago.
Here's my two cents worth I received a simple knitted dishcloth from a knitting group friend. I used it the other day and it was like Needless to say, I have a bag full of cotton yarn now.
I'll be busy for awhile. OK, I know it's an old thread, but I just couldn't help myself! I am so with you on this one! Yes they do work, but so do the store bought ones, which are way cheaper and don't require any effort on my part. I do think that the attraction is the simplicity of the pattern and how quickly you can make them. Personally, I see them like Christmas fruitcake, regift, regift, regift, lol!
I use the wash cloth patterns, with slight yarn adjustments, for afghan squares. Then use those squares to make dog beds for shelters or afghans for charity or to sew together for other items like wraps. Jilllouise 12 years ago. Hopefully someone will respond to this, as I see it's been talked about for quite some time!
I am new to knitting and only use the garter stitch when making the dishcloths. I know how to crochet better, but I like the look of the knitted ones First, I was wondering what size needles you use, especially if you want it to be used for a face cloth and if you only do the garter stitch, how can you make it square?
Mine always turns out oblong! I love the colors and love to make them and give them as gifts also. I would like to learn some new easy patterns HI, first time posting here.. I have read about the dishcloths.. I think they are great and a nice way to learn a new stitch.
This is to help out Jullouise, There is a dishcloth out there that you knit and should turn out to be square. Pattern, Size Finished size is 9 inches square.
Make yours larger or smaller by increasing more or fewer stitches. Instructions: Cast on 4 stitches. Knit 1, yarn over, knit to the end of the row. Continue in this manner until you have 50 stitches on your needle. Knit 1, yarn over, knit two together, knit until you are three stitches from the end of the row, then knit 2 together and knit one.
Continue in this manner until 4 stitches remain. Bind off. Weave in ends. I crochet these dishrags. My family, friends and co-worker BEG me for them. MrsMartin'sthings 8 years ago. I used a knitted dishcloth for the first time this year as it was provided for us at our holiday accommodation. I loved it!!!!! I have been knitting them myself and they are loved by everyone who uses them.
I don't know why anyone thought they weren't absorbent. Just ask for dishcloth yarn and you can't go wrong. Has anyone ever used this yarn to knit dishcloths? Dandelion Salad 7 years ago. Lots of colors to choose from, too. Seem very durable. I also use Filatura Lanarota Cozy Cotton which has some very lovely colors. These make great potholders if you go down a size on your needle. This cloth is made from Dishie: www. My other adult son loves the cloths I make for him. He tends to use them as trivets to put hot pans on.
This is a really old thread but I just saw it and would like to put my 2 cents in. I used to make these dishcloths both knitted and crochet years ago and loved them. I got away from the craft 9 years ago when I discovered Facebook. Well its time to back off and get back at crocheting and knitting.
Grandbabies need blankets LOL!. Anyway these cloths are great, especially the knitted ones. They work great! Just started my first one. Tee Flemming 6 years ago. I agree with the original poster somewhat. I don't find that they are not absorbent, but I really don't like them. I find they get pretty smelly If I do use the one or two that I have people gifted to me I tend to nuke them in the microwave after I've used them to keep the smelly out.
I much rather my microfibre ones. They clean better, they wash better, and they don't get smelly. Nobody I know agrees with me on this point though Guess I'm just smell sensitive. Use "Sugar and Cream" by Lily. Fabulous - best dish cloths ever. The yarns come in a variety of colors both solid and variegated.
0コメント